This website is part of the community Taskforce initiative

Submission details

52 +55/-3 votes

Recycle Bin confirmations

Submitted by wasker on June 8, 2008 to Bug, Usability

There's an option for displaying confirmation dialog when deleting a file to Recycle Bin. Turning off this option will turn off the dialog when user presses Delete key. The dialog still appears when user presses Shift-Del (permanent delete). Behavior is correct in both cases.

However, if there's no Recycle Bin on the drive for some reason (say, USB flash stick), "delete to Recycle Bin" becomes "permanent delete" BUT confirmation dialog isn't shown. This leads to accidental unrecoverable data loss.

Shell must detect cases when Recycle Bin is absent and ask user for confirmation even if the confirmation option was turned off.

In fact, the shell is aware of "absent Recycle Bin" situation (Delete File dialog is being displayed instead of Delete To Recycle Bin when the confirmation option is ON), so the behavior when there's no Recycle Bin and no confirmation displayed might be considered as a bug.

High

High

Not fixed

Discussion (5 comments)

eried wrote on June 8, 2008, 9:26pm

Yes. I posted this in other suggestion about the recycle bin as a comment. Drives me crazy when I delete some things in my pendrive without having an undo option as usual.

wasker wrote on June 8, 2008, 10:39pm

Yes, and thanks for that, @eried. I tested your comment and filed as another suggestion here, so it won't be lost.

balupton wrote on June 13, 2008, 12:05am

Where is this option to turn off that confirm dialog?

QuiescentWonder wrote on June 13, 2008, 1:01am

I was about to suggest this exact thing.

wasker wrote on June 13, 2008, 3:09am

@balupton: It's in Recycle Bin properties.

You might also be interested in...